Showing posts with label In Memoriam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label In Memoriam. Show all posts
Sunday, February 24, 2013
Hey Oscar, Why Didn't You Mention Ann Rutherford in your "In Memoriam" segment?
I have blogged before about how the Academy Award's "In Memoriam" section leaves out people who have made valuable and indisputable contributions to the movies, and how hurtful it is to the families and friends of loved ones who get ignored by the Academy year after year in this category. It feels strange to now have to blog from the perspective of being one of those slighted friends. The Academy failed to mention Ann Rutherford, who passed away last June. Ann was a good friend and I had no doubt that she would be included in the Oscar "In Memoriam" section. I was shocked that Ann was short shrifted by the Academy, along with Andy Griffith, Larry Hagman, Harry Carey Jr., and other notables. Her career encompassed appearances in over 50 feature films in a 15 year period. Some of those films include "A Christmas Carol" (1938) where she played the Ghost of Christmas Past, "Gone with the Wind" (1939) where she played Scarlett O'Hara's sister Carreen, "Pride & Prejudice" (1940), "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty" (1947), and over a dozen appearances as Mickey Rooney's girlfriend Polly Benedict in the "Andy Hardy" series that stretched from the Depression through World War II. I shouldn't have to build a case for why Ann should have been included. Her work speaks for itself. You can look up her credits on IMDB here.
During her film career, Ann Rutherford was under contract to Republic Pictures (where she made Westerns with John Wayne), and then MGM for almost 7 years, and then 20th Century-Fox. She shrewdly dealt with powerful studio heads like Louis B. Mayer and Darryl F. Zanuck during her lifetime. Ann was always proud to have been part of moviemaking in the classic era of Hollywood. I hesitate to speak on her behalf, but I have a strong feeling that she would have been hurt and disappointed had she known she was excluded from Oscar's "In Memoriam" section. Ann was a great unofficial goodwill Ambassador for Hollywood. Even though she had long been retired, she still had an active interest in the movies and her tastes were much more eclectic than one would expect. She was proud to be a voting member of the Academy. I recall how she greatly enjoyed "The Kids are Alright" (2010), which refutes the notion that older Academy members like herself are not open-minded about modern, cutting-edge material. Turner Classic Movies still outclasses the Academy with their annual "TCM Remembers" reel because the people who prepare it are much more inclusive, and have much more reverence and respect for both the film personnel it honors and film aficionados, than the Academy. As I said before, TCM honors the average film buff, while the Academy just honors themselves.
I'm glad that Ann is not here to witness the sort of politicking on display that others have resorted to in order to ensure their place on the "In Memoriam" list this year. The "In Memoriam" segment is the one section of the Oscars where there should be neither competition nor campaigning. By choosing to decide who gets to be included or excluded, the Academy is not just passing judgment on one performance, or one particular piece of work, but the entire body and value of a person's career. The rationale for who gets included or short-shrifted in the "In Memoriam" segment still baffles my mind. The Academy, in the past, has made excuses for short shrifting people like Farrah Fawcett in their "In Memoriam" section, claiming that she was better known for her TV work and they would leave it to the Emmys to honor people like Fawcett. I still do not understand why the Academy does not dispense with its stupid comedy routines and musical numbers and add more minutes to the "In Memoriam" segment so that even more people can be included. It would spare everyone involved a lot of grief and heartache if they did, because it's important for family and friends of a loved one who is gone, especially soon after they have passed away, to see them appropriately acknowledged by their Industry. To borrow an expression that Ann liked to use when she was annoyed, it's apparent to me that the Academy is run by "Card-Carrying Idiots." Ann Rutherford's body of work in motion pictures warranted her inclusion in this year's "In Memoriam" section, so what's your excuse this time, Oscar, hmmm?
Labels:
A Christmas Carol,
Academy Award,
Ann Rutherford,
Gone with the Wind,
In Memoriam,
Oscar,
Pride and Prejudice,
The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
Tuesday, December 18, 2012
A Grateful Acknowledgement to "TCM Remembers"
Turner Classic Movies has released its annual "TCM Remembers" tribute to film professionals who died during the calendar year of 2012. You can see it here. As I have mentioned before on this blog, my own father died last month. The reason I mention it again is because, more than ever, I realize the importance of acknowledging the presence and contributions of people who are no longer with us. I have always admired the "TCM Remembers" tributes much more than the annual Oscar "In Memoriam" segments during the Academy Awards ceremony because "TCM" Remembers" tends to be very inclusive in terms of who gets acknowledged. I remember being heartened at how, in 2008, TCM included such names as Vampira ("Plan 9 from Outer Space"), Hazel Court ("Premature Burial," "The Masque of the Red Death" and "The Raven"), Julie Ege ("On Her Majesty's Secret Service," "Creatures the World Forgot" and "Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires"), and Roberta Collins ("The Big Doll House," "Caged Heat," and "Death Race 2000")--all cult movie stars dear to the hearts of us film aficionados, but who you don't really expect the Academy to acknowledge. I recall that the esteemed Lois Nettleton--whose film credits include "Period of Adjustment" (1962), "Come Fly With Me" (1963), "Mail Order Bride" (1964), "The Good Guys and the Bad Guys" (1969), "Dirty Dingus Magee" (1970), "The Man in the Glass Booth" (1975), Wes Craven's "Deadly Blessing" (1981), and "The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas" (1982)--was excluded from the Academy Awards "In Memoriam" tribute for 2008, but was included in the "TCM Remembers" tribute reel for that same year. TCM seems to have a more consistent, logical standard with which they choose who gets included in their annual tributes. Even if they can't include everyone who may have worked in the movies who died in a calendar year, they at least try to cast as wide a net as possible. The Academy seems much more random and arbitrary in terms of their selections.
I was already troubled by the Academy's "In Memoriam" the year they excluded Dorothy McGuire and Peggy Lee, but included the tragic singer Aaliyah, who had only recently died in a plane crash. In 2010, I was reminded of their strange standard of review when Michael Jackson's death was acknowledged, but Farrah Fawcett's was not. The reason they gave was that Fawcett was better known for her television work and that they would leave it up to the Emmys to acknowledge her. If that's the case, then Michael Jackson should have been excluded as well, and left up to the Grammys to remember him, because he was better known for his music than for anything he did in the movies. Fawcett was indeed known for her TV work, but she also appeared in such feature films as Claude Lelouch's "Love is a Funny Thing" (1969) with Jean-Paul Belmondo; Myra Breckinridge" (1970); "Logan's Run" (1976); "Somebody Killed Her Husband" (1979); "Sunburn" (1979); "Saturn 3" (1980) directed by Stanley Donen; "The Cannonball Run" (1981); "Extremities" (1986); "See You in the Morning" (1989); "Man of the House" (1995) with Chevy Chase; Robert Duvall's acclaimed "The Apostle" (1997); and Robert Altman's "Dr. T and the Women" (2000). Fawcett more than qualified to be included in that year's Academy Awards "In Memoriam" section.
It's been said before, but I'll say it again: the Academy wastes precious air time with dumb musical numbers and comedy routines that no one really wants to see. I would prefer it if they got rid of those sections and added more minutes to the "In Memoriam" section so that it could be more comprehensive and inclusive than it is now. I realize that the Academy Awards are purportedly about celebrating excellence (ahem) in the cinema, but when it comes to the "In Memoriam" section, they really need to keep a more open mind about including people who may not be as acclaimed or as popular or as famous as the people they tend to choose. There are a lot of professionals, in front of and behind the cameras, who have built careers in both films AND television. It's an industry where the two mediums enjoy a very symbiotic relationship. And just because a person found more success in one medium doesn't negate their contributions in the other. I just feel that the decision-making process that the Academy chooses is far too arbitrary to be accurately representative of the kinds of people who have made contributions to the movies. I don't expect them to ever really change their policy on this issue, so that's why I'm glad TCM continues to do a good job with their "TCM Remembers" tributes. Sometimes, I feel TCM gets a little overrated by us movie aficionados because it is simply a repository of movies in their catalogue that they run in rotation. And, as much as I like Robert Osborne as well, I think we also overrate him a little because of his role in hosting the programming on that channel. As knowledgeable as he is, he didn't actually make the movies he introduces. I get the feeling people forget that distinction when they praise both him and that channel. But, at the end of the day, I still love them because they actually show respect and acknowledgement to us movie aficionados, as reflected in their attention to detail when they put together tributes such as "TCM Remembers." TCM actually honors those of us who are film aficionados, rather than the Academy, which simply honors themselves.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











